Book Reviews

All The Light We Cannot See


Author: Anthony Doerr

Pages: 544 (Paperback)

Publisher: Fourth Estate

Release Date: May 6, 2014

Source: I bought this book myself

Buy it on Book Depository


“All The Light We Cannot See”, by Anthony Doerr, follows the story of Werner, a German orphan who dreams of becoming a scientist and escaping the horror of the mines that took his father, and Marie-Laure, a French girl that became blind when she was six-years-old and that learned her way around Paris by studying a wooden model of her neighbourhood, built by her father.

In the synopsis at the back of the book it says “a future which draws her (Marie-Laure) ever closer to Werner”. Additionally the third chapter in the book is called “The Girl” and talks about Marie-Laure, while the fourth is named “The Boy” and introduces Werner. What would you expect? A beautiful romance between a German soldier and a blind, French girl who’s town had been invaded. SPOILERS AHEAD: forget the happy-ever-after.

This book made me angry, it really did. It was on page 483 – yes, I can tell you the exact page – that I felt like hurling the book out of the window. Why? Because “All The Light We Cannot See” talks about reality. There is no happy-ever-after in wars, there is only fear, death and destruction. My edition had 530 pages, but Werner and Marie-Laure only truly meet on page 467. That is a hell of a lot of time building up to this moment. I was all hopeful that this was finally it, the romance was here, it was all so beautiful and then my heart was suddenly crushed. And that is what war does… At first I felt betrayed by the writer, but I blame myself for expecting another sloppy, hopeful war romance. We, as readers, always crave for happy endings, but that is what’s so great about “All The Light We Cannot See” – it doesn’t give you what you want, but the cruel, raw reality. What happened to Frederic broke my heart and what happened to Werner destroyed my soul, especially because he was my favourite character.

One thing I didn’t like about this book: the long, long descriptions, especially when writing in Marie-Laure’s point of view. As she was blind, she focused a lot on smells and noises, but sometimes the descriptions were absolutely useless and were just there to fill another half-page. Another thing that annoyed me was the enumerations. The characters were always counting heartbeats or steps or minutes. This was recurring and eventually I was so tired of it I had to put the book down for a while. I also don’t understand why Anthony Doerr decided to have flash-forwards and flash-backwards. I actually would have preferred if it was all in chronological order, but I guess that by giving a sneak peek of what was going to happen in the future, he spiced up the curiosity in the reader.

However, I did like the fact that chapters alternated between Werner and Marie-Laure so that you weren’t too long without one character. The fact that we watch their stories unfold side by side and discover that they already knew each other without knowing each other (this will make sense when you read the book, trust me :p) feels like they were destined to meet from the start. You root for this one moment when they meet and that makes it worth the 466 pages before that. Additionally, there is a magical element in this book which seemed a bit out of place taking into account the realism of the rest of the story, but it did add some interest to the book, especially because the reader is left to wonder if there was really any magic in it.

The book is actually written in present tense, which I thought would drive me crazy – it has happened in other books – but it didn’t. “All The Light We Cannot See” is beautifully written and the language flows so it didn’t bother me at all.

highly recommend “All The Light We Cannot See” – it is heart-breaking and annoying but totally worth it. I wouldn’t describe it as “a page-turner” like Guardian did because I did grow bored in some parts, but for those who like historical fiction this is certainly a most-read. The last chapter was especially touching because it is set in 2014 and indirectly compares the young generation of nowadays with the ones that lived through WW2. Now, children play war games in the computer where their characters are killed, “But I can always begin again”, while the people that died in WW2 never had a chance of getting their lives back. “All The Light We Cannot See” masterfully depicts the injustice and futility of war, how armies accomplish nothing but the destruction of what is good and innocent.

7 thoughts on “All The Light We Cannot See

  1. Thanks for your comment AJ! Yup, I'm a little obsessed with it too – I'm still trying to process my feelings and I think that it will take a while :p
    The thing about being long was that in the end I was just like – “I read all this, ALL THIS, so that in the end you do this to me. Anthony Doerr, don't you have any mercy for my heart?”
    At least I'm not as angry as I was yesterday. I truly have a love-hate relationship with this book :D


  2. This is definitely a book that has stayed with me – I finished it a couple of years ago. I agree that it is a slow read but I was enjoying it so much by 3/4 way through that I ended up not wanting it to finish.


  3. I absolutely agree with you, Helen. The book was rather slow at first but it was really on the last 25% of the book that I started loving the story and always wanting to know what was going to happen next. This book will definitely stay with me as well – it is one of those you just can't forget.
    Thanks for your comment, by the way :)


  4. It took me a while to get into this book but I thought the language was beautiful. I wasn't that angry about the story, I didn't think there was any way they could be together, so I didn't expect it. It was very sad, though. My father-in-law is from the area of Germany where Werner grew up, and he would only be a little younger.


  5. The fact that your father-in-law is from there is awesome! It kind of gives a new feeling to the story, right? By the way, I too thought that the language was absolutely beautiful. Yes, the book dragged on a bit at first, but it was definitely worth the read!

    Thanks for your comment :)


  6. I agree with you. Really far from having a light at the end of the tunnel… I remember reading it during my last Summer break and wanting to bawl in front of everyone at the pool. Such a great novel (and a great review!)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s